DVD In My Pants
DIMP Contests
Disc Stats
Video: 2.35:1
Anamorphic: Yes
Audio:
English (Dolby Digital 5.1)
Spanish (2.0 Surround)
Subtitles:
English, Spanish, French
Runtime: 92 minutes
Rating: R
Released: July 15, 2008 
Production Year: 2008
Director: David R. Ellis
Released by:
Fox Home Entertainment
Region: 1 NTSC
Disc Extras
David R. Ellis’ dignity
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
Asylum
By John H. Felix
ADVERTISEMENT
In a distant, spooky, ill-defined past, a mysterious and creepy psychologist named Doctor Burke was getting tired of his ice pick lobotomies and instead took to carving up his patients for fun, profit and I’m assuming sexual kicks, too. Alas, the fun had to stop sometime, and Doctor Burke was lynched by his own patients. Cut to many years later only to find that generic asylum has turned into generic college dorm room – and thanks to the wonders of its clueless, party-friendly inhabitants, the ghost of Doctor Burke has been unleashed, ready to wreck havoc on the newly enrolled fresh meat.

At least, I think it’s the ghost of Doctor Burke, you see, he has many ghostly powers, such as teleporting his victims back into their own tragic pasts to break them down psychologically, or being able to teleport himself, appearing and disappearing at will, you know, spooky shit. And yet Doctor Burke seems to have trouble with barricaded doors, pans and retarded groundskeepers.

That basically separates Doctor Burke from Freddy Krueger. Freddy was an unstoppable force of evil… Sleep… Demon… Pedophile… Fire… Demon… Okay, Freddy Krueger’s general mythology is pretty nonsensical, but at least you couldn’t stun him by hitting him in the head with a pan. Freddy doesn’t die by getting stabbed in the head, Doctor Burke does. Let’s not ever forget that Freddy doesn’t launch into an absurd, touchy-feely speech before each kill scene talking about his victim’s feelings. What we have here is a film attempting to create a new killer who can’t even decide what his own rules are.

For those who were waiting for David R. Ellis’ follow-up to Snakes on a Plane, look no further: Asylum is here, direct-to-video and ready for your viewing pleasure. If you’re on the fence about Asylum, let me be the one to tell you that this film features a spooky, middle-aged groundskeeper who warns its teenage protagonists about the possibilities of shit hitting the fan. Yes, it’s that kind of movie.

Let me also be the one to break it to you that Asylum is basically a beat-by-beat recreation of many Nightmare on Elm Street films, only in an asylum-turned-college-dormitory setting. And we’re not talking the prestige first film, the excellent Dream Warriors of the so-bad-it’s-utterly-fascinating-on-a-Freudian-level Freddy’s Revenge, no; I’m talking full on, balls-out Dream Child and Final Nightmare-era Elm Street films. It’s nutty, it’s retarded, it’s ill conceived, but, sadly, it isn’t as fun. Yes, I said Dream Child was fun, not good. In fact, it’s my least favorite of the series, for the record, but it’s still more watchable than Asylum.

I would create a horror movie new sliding scale featuring Asylum at the far, far end of it, but I can’t because I’ve also had to sit through Insanitarium.

 

Presentation
Let’s address the elephant in the room because I don’t feel that many DVD reviewers are willing to point out how douchebaggy it is for FOX to send out bugged DVD-R screeners. And it’s just not smaller “indie-“minded sites like DVDINMYPANTS.COM – go to any DVD review site, and you’ll find a nice-sized chunk of people saying the exact same thing: “I cannot properly evaluate the presentation of this DVD because Fox has sent me what amounts to bootleg wares.” Not only would they be absolutely correct, I am going to take the same exact route: I cannot properly evaluate the presentation of this DVD because Fox has sent me what amounts to bootleg wares.

And it’s completely reasonable when you think about it – FOX wants to protect their shitty property. If they were really smart, they’d start dropping discs off at the steps of ATMs for free and harassing Sylvester Stallone, Damon Packard-style.

All I know is that the film was sent to me on a DVD-R that doesn’t even take up half of the disc’s space. The entirety of Asylum takes up roughly 2.3 gigabytes of a 4.39-gigabyte disc. My only hope is that FOX was classy enough to send me a rewritable DVDR so I can replace it with something much more important, like pornography. Then I’ll mail it back. Hope you like Eurocreme videos, FOX.

Extras
Due to the nature of the disc, I expected to be getting just the film itself but it turns out that the retail disc for Asylum comes with the same exact specs of the screener I received: nothing at all. Boooooooo!

The Bottom Line
The copy of Shutter that Fox sent to me was scratched up and unplayable. Asylum came in without any problems whatsoever. I still feel wronged that both discs didn’t come broken in dozens of small, edible pieces.


1.5
Feature - Generic clunker.
-
Video - Not available for evaluation.
-
Audio - Not available for evaluation.
-
Extras - Not available in general.
1.5
Star Star Star Star Star Overall







Copyright © 2007 DVD In My Pants, L.L.C.. All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy | Legal Disclaimer